2018 post-event blog 2:

Future for EU farming: Could EU agriculture survive without the CAP?

Friday, Apr 06, 2018

Speaking at FFA2018, Phil Hogan, the Commissioner for Agriculture and Rural Development, told the forum that he and his colleagues are in the final stages of reshaping the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP).

The Commission plan will “bring European farming and food production fully and firmly into the 21st century, placing it at the heart of our international commitments on climate and sustainability,” he explained.

The new CAP delivery model will be firmly based on performance and results, with one streamlined strategic plan to be designed by each EU country, encompassing all aspects of the policy. It will include common rules to tie farmers’ income support to environment- and climate-friendly farming practices. Member states will be able to tailor entry-level environmental and climate measures best suited to their local conditions.

The new combination of mandatory and voluntary measures will provide national authorities and farmers with greater flexibility. “The whole package will therefore help farmers to follow various avenues of ‘smart’ agriculture, including precision farming,” the Commissioner said.
It is also designed to give farmers confidence in an attractive and rewarding career path. “Sustainability is not just a question of the environment. We must also ensure the sustainability of our farmers’ incomes,” he insisted.

Mr Hogan firmly denied any suggestion that the changes amounted to a renationalisation of the CAP. The updated policy did not “in any way, shape or form” give member states a free hand and the Commission “will remain the sole guarantor of the policy and the engine of our new delivery model”.

Jean Arthuis, Chair of the European Parliament’s Committee on Budgets, agreed that the CAP’s overall aim was to ensure the competitiveness of European farming, while protecting the climate and the environment. “Therefore, it is clear research and innovation have to be stimulated,” he advised.

The French MEP pointed to the need for stabilisation measures to cushion farmers from price volatility. This, he suggested, could be achieved by building up financial reserves, out with the annual expenditure, for use in crises.

Ariel Brunner, Senior Head of Policy for Europe and Central Asia, Birdlife International, maintained that Commissioner Hogan’s presentation of the new CAP contained no analysis of real problems and was devoid of very specific objectives. “The question is: are we going to see a CAP for change or a CAP for business as usual?” he asked.

Ariane Lotti, an agricultural entrepreneur and Managing Partner at Tenuta San Carlo, running a 480 hectare multifunctional and diversified farm, explained how drought and other factors had turned 2017 into an extremely difficult year for her business.

“As we think about the future of the CAP, we need to think about a vision and also about years like 2017,” she said, explaining that in times of crisis CAP finance plays a crucial role in managing cash flow.
Philipp Schulze Esking, Member of the Board and Vice President, of the German Agricultural Society and a pig farmer, urged the CAP to set new incentives with measurable indicators for farmers to be more sustainable. This would help farmers decide on the measures to take and give society a better understanding of how financial subsidies are used. “Then, we would really get on the right track.”

To watch videos from FFA2018 click here >

More blogs & summaries

2024 Annual Conference summary – Inspirational talks

Sharing journeys towards a sustainable future

2024 Annual Conference summary – Session 4 and closing

How to fund the transition?

2024 Annual Conference summary – Session 3

What levers can the EU pull to deliver systemic change and what did we learn?

2024 Annual Conference summary – Call to Action progress

Call to Action progress report

2024 Annual Conference summary – Session 2

The need for systemic change

2024 Annual Conference summary – Introduction and session 1

Restoring the opportunity for food system transformation

2024 Research lessons to inform future CAP reform event summary

Enhancing agricultural sustainability via trade policy

Responses to our Regenerative Agriculture survey

Forum update July 2023

2023 Regional Event Spain event summary